There’s this flaw in “Into Darkness”


I’ve seen “Star Trek Into Darkness” twice now. I don’t think it’s as good as the first reboot film, but it’s better than I feared. And there’s a massive logical flaw towards the end that probably no one besides me cares about. But I hate it.

The thing I disliked about the first film was its whole premise, the altered timeline. I don’t want an alternative future developing without Vulcan. So even if the film was very good, I worried where its sequels would take us.

On that score there’s no problem in this film. Sort of a reworked homage to “The Wrath of Khan” (also the second film in its series), it works. I especially like the revamp of the climactic scene from the end with the roles of Kirk and Spock reversed.

There are flaws…there’s no explanation for the weird landscape on Qo’noS (a supposedly deserted province is covered with buildings, albeit in ruins), the scene with actress Alice Eve in her underwear was totally unnecessary, and while Benedict Cumberbatch was great in his role, the role of Khan required either someone who looks like Ricardo Montalan or who looks like a Sikh.

It’s as if Brad Pitt was supposed to be playing Jackie Robinson.

But it’s the logical flaw at the end that really bothers me.

(Spoiler alert)

The shoot out in space supposedly happens close to the Earth, only 280,000 kilometers away. That’s closer than the Moon, so the part about being pulled towards the Earth after the battle works.

But there’s no way that shoot out can take place so close to such a huge audience, to make any sense at all it has to be secret. At that distance, not only would the whole planet be watching, the surrounding space would be filled with ships. No way comms would be out, no way the admiral would be allowed to destroy another federation ship, no way there wouldn’t be ships and space stations helping the crashing Enterprise.

So why do it that way? Does JJ Abrams think we’re too dumb to care? (It’s a bit like there being absolutely no ships left close by when Alderaan gets destroyed. Where’d they all go?)


What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: